Read the transcript
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd slip.
With great power comes great responsibility. If you don't have both, that's big problem. I was still the founder, the owner, the leader as opposed to the manager. Okay? And separating that is very important. To make bacon and eggs, the chicken is involved, but the pig is committed. Welcome to My Shout, the podcast where we have candid conversations about family business transition. Today's guest is David Werdiger, bestselling author and educator who spent most of his life thinking about what one generation leaves to the next, both professionally and personally.
Youngest of five, David didn't succeed into the family business. He forged his own path, building and eventually selling a billing telco business back in 2025. In this episode, we'll talk about what it's like to be born into a wealthy, prominent family, choosing to forge your own path, and the lessons that journey provides regarding control, relevance and legacy. So David, thanks for coming on the show, mate. Cheers. - L'chaim. - So, all right. Well, thanks for coming on the show. Pleasure. Thanks for - inviting me. - No, it's all good.
I've just been thinking about something you said to me a while ago about growing up in a, you know, in a family business, and particularly about being the youngest of a few with a, call it a large age gap. Was just moving into the family business even, not unlikely, but less likely because you weren't the elder, or was it a genuine choice to not join? I think I had the choice. Okay? Because I think older siblings don't have, don't, in some families don't have the choice. My brother, he's 10 years older than me.
The other family members who were in the business, my cousin, he was an only son, and my brother-in-law. But they were all also around 10-plus years older than me. So that exacerbates that age gap. You know, my family, there were four kids born in the space of about five and a half years, five-and-a-half-year gap, and then me. Miracle, accident, whatever you wanna call it, serendipity. So I was already an outlier from birth. And as I was coming here, I recalled that we are about 100 metres from my dad's factory in Gore Street, Fitzroy.
And I love the name of this street, Easey Street. You would want to just live on Easey Street. 100%. And I remember coming here with my dad and working when I was a kid and when I was a student, and it was just expected. But then, as I went through uni, I said, "You know, I'd like to do some work," and there was some work available, made available. You know, a part-time or casual job made available to me. But then when I finished uni, I always felt very self-conscious in the business because I was this little kid, you know.
Everyone else was adults, but everyone... There was nobody my age who was involved in the business at all. So that sort of amplified that feeling of being different and always wondering what people thought of me. And that's... I read this fascinating article about identity, in... and there's two forms of identity. There's sort of intrinsic identity, and then there's this identity that's imposed on you that you learn by the way other people treat you, and that second identity was actually quite significant in my life because we grew up in a community where we were a close-knit community.
We were known to be very well off in that community, and I think people treated me a certain way because of that. And that, you know, influenced my sense of self. In a good way, in a bad way, I don't know. But whatever it was, it contributed to my identity. So I've got this sense that, you know, I'm different. I'm going to work, and I'm thinking, "What's gonna happen, you know, 10, 20 years from now? Am I gonna be these people's boss? What are they thinking about me?" Why should I be worrying about this?
I don't know, but I was. And that was one thing. The other thing was the business was in textile manufacturing and commercial property, okay? When I went to study, I was very good at maths, and I was very bad at the humanities. I actually failed matric English. And I'm studying and I'm doing maths and statistics and computer science, and I'm thinking, "What career does that naturally go into?" It goes into a career in IT, and that was the, you know, the job I ended up taking, was a software developer.
And I'm looking at the business and I'm saying, "What role is there for me in this business?" There was not an obvious fit. The other thing that was I guess in the back of my mind is what would it be like to work with family, and would I be like a, you know, a bit of a third wheel? And I was a bit concerned. I didn't think that I... that there was a natural place for me. But being the youngest, I'm blessed that there was already somebody there.
If there wasn't, I think there would've been a lot of pressure, implied or otherwise, on me to say, "No, you really ought to join. It's what you're supposed to do." Yeah, it was interesting. That was exactly what I was thinking, which is if it... To your point, being the youngest means that there's maybe less obligation. Then equally, had you been the first, do you think your life would've been very different? Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Birth order, you know, there are people who apply, you know, firstborn, this, you know, these archetypes.
And I don't like archetypes because sometimes we take the situation and fit it to a particular model. That said, there's totally something to it. And you see it in a lot of families. And yeah, I'm very much the prototypical youngest by a big gap, spoiled little one, who didn't have to join the business, who got it easier than everybody else, and everybody knows it, and treats him that way for it. So how... You also mentioned growing up in a prominent family in the - community. - Yeah.
So I imagine it's not just your family who treat you slightly differently because of the age gap and you being the youngest, and it's not just the business that treats you differently and the staff because you're the younger sibling or part of the empire or whatever it looks like, but there's also the community within which you roll. How does that shape where you decide to take yourself, do you think? Yeah. And that was significant, okay? 'Cause we're a, you know, a close-knit Jewish community, and my parents were, you know, very communally involved.
But we were, I don't know if we were the wealthiest family in the community at the time, maybe, maybe not, but certainly perceived as such. And that means you get teased. Okay? I remember in school somebody teased me because my dad owned a supermarket. It wasn't a supermarket, it was a large shopping centre. And I felt... You know, it's not, not enjoyable being teased. I was also probably teased because I was the last person picked in any sporting things in school, and that was just, you know, a function of natural ability at the time.
But neither of those things you can control. And, I mean, the other thing is, at the time, I was not particularly... what's the best way to say it? Socially aware. Yeah. Fair enough. I was a geek. Okay? An introverted geek is what I was back then. Which means I didn't really have the emotional tools to deal with this. And as a family, we were very much trauma-informed. You know, my parents' experience during the war, my father was a slave labourer in Auschwitz. He, by the end of the war, when he was liberated, he was nearly dead.
The term used is the... is Muselmann, and that is a person who's just waiting to die. And so only my father and one of his brothers survived. My grandfather, he died of typhus, only a few weeks before they were liberated, which was devastating for my father. And my father spent four years convalescing in Switzerland after the war, so he was pretty sick. And you know what? I sort of try to... And again, for years, he didn't speak about the war. I have these weird memories of nightmares, and I can't, but I can't place them of my father having nightmares, but I really...
It's a blur. It was only in the mid-'80s when the release of a movie called Shoah from Claude Lanzmann, a movie that went for nine hours and we all had to go watch it on two consecutive Sunday afternoons. My father sort of said, "You know what? I have to start talking about this even though it's very painful," and he did, and it was painful. And my uncle, who lived in New York, never spoke to his kids about it. So any time we would hear anything about my father's war experience, our cousins would say, "What did Uncle Nossen say?" We were hungry.
I'm a, I'm into genealogy, and I think part of it came from that because I love puzzles. And for me, genealogy is a puzzle. Trying to piece together bits... I have bits of information from different sources. How can I put them together in... into a coherent picture of what my family was? And so that trauma-informed family... You know, my mother grew up in the Soviet Union. She was shipped off to Uzbekistan during the war. My grandfather on her side, he was in the Soviet army. Again, a very, very difficult war experience.
So in our family, you just don't talk about bad stuff. Okay? And then you get even better than that. You just don't talk about anything important. Nothing to see here. Everything's fine. So that's the environment I grew up in. So didn't really learn to communicate till much later. So I'm curious then, genealogy question for you, or puzzle perhaps, is being the youngest and in that environment, was just all the words taken up by the older ones, and so you decided to be quieter? Or is it a biological thing, do you reckon?
They called me shy back then. Introverted was probably a better term. Comfortable with myself. Didn't have a voice. It was not... You know, my sister, one of my sisters, we used to call her the emotional one because she expressed emotions. And I realise now that she was actually the normal one. We were all repressing our emotions. I'm curious about the family being, I guess, coming from a place of trauma informed, how do you think that led to you deciding to build something of your own? Yeah, okay.
So, finished uni, didn't see a place for myself in the business, but also had a desire to get a job on my merits, and this was something I told a girl on a date once. She said, "Why didn't you join the family business?" And I said to her, "I want to get... wanted to get a job using what I know, not whom I know." Which would be counterintuitive for any other person than normally business advice, right? It's who you know. It is who you know, but to get my start, I wanted to attribute that to myself, okay?
And yes, the easy route is I knew that a job was available for me. I had misgivings about what that might look like and whether I'd find fulfilment there. But getting a job myself was really important to be able to do that. So that's what I did. And my mother wanted me to do honours because I had an offer to do honours, but by after three years of uni, I had enough already. I'd worked really, really p... hard, particularly in second year. Like did way too, you know, an overload.
And by third year, I had enough, and I was itching to get a job and start earning some money and be on that journey. So got the jo- applied for a job, got it, and started working, and that was for a stockbroking firm. I was developing real-time stock market information systems and I was a quant analyst. And that was where I fell in love with options, exchange-traded options and derivatives and time as a concept, which now I see was a really important thread. So I'll sort of take that thread through the discussion.
But I'm working on a job, and I'm not working on a job like I'm on a job because I don't know what that looks like. I'd never been an employee before. You know, when you worked in the business, you... I had a sense that one day this will be mine or something like that. So I didn't work on it like it was a job. I worked on it, did whatever needed to be done. And in my first job, you know, I'd go in early, I'd stay back late, and not, you know, not clock in at nine and leave at five.
Nothing like that. And, but then, you know, did that for a few years and thought, "No, this is not my future. My future is not a path in a... in employment and advancing through a company. I know business. I want to be in business." So I started my own business, which was initially a software development business. And when I say a business, it was barely even that because I owned a job. I left employment, and I was contracting and going from one job to the next, developing custom software.
And I realised that what I was selling was my time. And time being, you know, the most limited resource in the world, most precious resource, there's only so many hours I can bill at a given rate. How am I gonna grow this business? Well, the way to grow a business like that is to find more work than you can do and employ other people to do that work. That would involve me not doing what I wanted to do. I just wanted to cut code 'cause that was what I enjoyed.
I didn't wanna sell. Ugh, that was very difficult and out of my comfort zone. So I did this for a few years and managed to get a bit of work and employ a couple of people and... But the business was not really growing until the mid-'90s where I came across an opportunity to develop a telecommunications billing system for somebody. And interestingly, all of the projects that I found myself doing were all heavy data projects, making sense of a lot of data. So there was this guy I met because we happened to be near each other in offices, and he said, "Oh, you're a software developer.
I need a billing system. Can you do that?" And I had never done anything like that before, so of course I said yes. Developed a billing system for him. I meet his Optus account executive, who's the beginnings of Optus Wholesale, which didn't really exist as wholesale back then, and he says to me, "I've got a number of other customers who could really do with some help with billing." And I have a bit of a light bulb moment where I say, "Oh, what if I could have a billing system and I could sell it to lots of people?
I wouldn't be selling time anymore. I'd be selling IP." And that's what I ended up doing. Pivoted the whole business to say, "I'm not gonna go project to project. I'm gonna focus on the billing." So my customers were all startup telcos, and startup telcos were not... did not have an appetite to spend six figures on a piece of software that would... needed to get them going. And one of my prospective customers said to me, "Look, I really love your billing system, and I need a billing system, but I don't wanna pay for it." And I said to him, "Okay.
Well, you know, last time I checked, I'm not a charity. What did you have in mind?" And he says, "I wanna lease it." Okay. And he was, you know, experienced in the industry and I said, "Okay. What does that mean?" He said, "Well, how about I pay you two percent of turnover?" And thus was born, it wasn't called SaaS back then, but, you know, the rev share model. And it was very successful because all these telcos are popping up and saying, you know, "We don't... We wanna spend money on marketing.
That's the best use of money for us." So I ended up leasing them the software and taking a clip of the ticket. What I was doing was taking a risk on their business 'cause some of them did well, and some of them bombed. Shifting from developing custom software into telco, that led me to start up two other telco businesses and partner in a couple of others 'cause I was in this whole telco ecosystem, and there was all this interesting stuff happening. I did all that because, and again, this is all in hindsight, okay?
I... much later I did a master's of entrepreneurship. First day of the master's, this is at Swinburne, very, very good course. And I've actually got a role there on the course advisory committee for entrepreneurship now. First day of the course they say, "Are entrepreneurs born or made?" And my response is, "This is bullshit. You've got a conflict of interest. You're in the business of selling people entrepreneurship degrees. Of course you're gonna say entrepreneurs are not born, they're made. Otherwise, you know, who's gonna do your course?" Of course, like everything, it's not a binary, but I think there is inside me that entrepreneur gene, whatever that means, a burning desire to create and build.
Yet, it was a burning desire to create and build something of my own as opposed to build somebody else's. And I understood my whole journey much later, when I was in a webinar with a gentleman by the name of Jay Hughes, who is considered the father of family office. And he was... I was, I'm at this webinar hearing him speak, and he's talking about a client of his, and he says, "This guy, he's in his mid-50s, and he's the custodian of somebody else's dreams rather than a creator of his own dreams." And when I heard him say those words so succinctly, I suddenly realised why I had done everything I had done.
Because I was... By the people around me, the identity was, "You are the son of. You are just part of this family. You're not you. You're just part of something else." And I had this burning desire inside of me to say, "No, I'm me. What is my mark on the world?" I needed to create my own dreams, to create my own businesses, and that's been my challenge, 'cause it is a challenge when you're born into a family, with a very successful parent, and that person is, you know, larger than life, very positive, knew what was best for everybody, including you, but not necessarily.
How to b- how to c- forge my own identity. That's been my life challenge. So I'm curious then, was there a tension between you forging your own way and the family going, "Well, hang on, that's wrong or different, or it's not what we expected," or was it all... What does that look like? If there was, it wasn't something we ever spoke about because we didn't really have the forum to speak about it. Okay. What's your role? From time to time I was asked to do things in the family enterprise, mostly relating to family philanthropy, and I took them on and did them to the best of my ability.
At one point my business was meandering and not doing much and my father said, "Close all that down and come and join me." And I said no. And it wasn't easy. It wasn't easy. But we didn't really have the sorts of discussions to say this is what's expected of you and going back to what we discussed earlier, that's the benefit of being the youngest. Not only being the youngest, but being in an environment where I was unchallenged, which is I guess good and bad. My parents were very, I guess prototypical of their generation.
"You're fantastic, you can do anything" is one message you're getting, but the other message is g- you're getting is "whatever you're doing isn't enough." My parents would regularly point to successful other people with the implication, "Why aren't you as successful as them?" But then at the same time, I had these messages saying, you know, "You're really smart, you can achieve anything." So, you know, one thing I did learn is the importance of communication and messaging that we give as parents to our children. But it was... I had a lot of...
I had what I call a safety net. You know, my parents were there because my businesses did not create huge wealth on my own. They did okay. They probably could have done better. But having that safety net w- meant that I was never at risk of being out on the street. So here's an interesting conundrum for you. Does that disprove your theory that entrepreneurs are born by virtue of, I don't have as m- I'm taking less of a risk? Well, this goes to the question of what are the ingredients of entrepreneurship?
Okay? One of them is a desire to create and build. Another one is an appetite for risk. Okay? I had an appetite for risk, but at the same time, that existed with a safety net, and I still have an appetite for risk. But they're two different things. If you have an appetite for risk, but you don't wanna build something, could you be an entrepreneur? Maybe you're better in something - else. - Oh, there's plenty of kids who just wanna spend mum and dad's money to buy Ferraris and be playboys, right?
They don't wanna build something. That's correct. That's neither appetite for risk nor desire to build. That's what I call... What do they call it? Affluenza. Okay? That's... The way I describe that is it's an unbalanced life because, you know, people talk about wealth and the greatest fear of parents is that their kids will be entitled. And what does entitled mean? You know, I grew up knowing we were wealthy. I grew up knowing that at some point in the future, I'll inherit one-fifth of something very big that we didn't talk about very much.
Okay? Does that mean I'm entitled knowing that that will happen? I don't know. Some people would say yes. So my definition of entitlement is privilege without obligation. Because everything's two sides. If you've just got privilege, just the benefits of wealth, then that's a very risky path. What am I... You know, it's a risk of not having purpose, which is, I think, the worst thing in the world. That's the greatest risk, not living an expensive lifestyle. 'Cause frankly, if the family can afford it, you know, is there a really good reason why you shouldn't?
Why you should live an ascetic lifestyle? I don't think so. On the other hand, if you have no sense of obligation that comes with it, and we're going back to, you could either say Voltaire or you could say Spider-Man's uncle, "With great power comes great responsibility." If you don't have both, that's big problem. That's a fair point. What about the entrepreneur, as you said earlier, who... a desire for build and a desire for risk, but as you described it, has the safety net. Do you see, through the entrepreneurship that you're working, the alternative, which is the entrepreneur mindset without the safety net, and do they fare differently?
There are plenty of very successful entrepreneurs who do get a helping hand from families. Now, so not all of them started from nothing. Not all of them had to raise money externally, which I didn't have to do. It's hard to say, but when I said I had a safety net, that had limits, first of all. Second of all, I still lay in bed at night wondering how I'm gonna make the next payroll. So risk appetite means, as, in entrepreneurship, to me it means giving up the security of employment and everything that comes with that, salary, benefits, Time off.
Time off, all of those things. Giving that up for uncertainty and diving off. I remember, we, when we did the master's of entrepreneurship, right? In the, one of the first units we do this thing called opportunity evaluation, and we form teams, and we develop an idea, and we sort of evaluate that idea, and we pitch it. And at the end of it, the lecturer said, "This is really good. Why aren't you guys going ahead and doing it?" And so the four of us, who were all gainfully employed at the time, I won't say employed 'cause some of us were self-employed, but we were busy.
We started meeting regularly saying, "How can we take this and turn this into a business?" And it turns out we were all chickens and not pigs. Okay. Do you know this one? - No. - No. All right. So, what's the difference between involved versus committed? Oh, I have heard this - before. - Yeah. Okay. So, you know, "Oh, this is a good idea. I wanna get involved." Okay? But am I committed to the extent that I'm going to give up what I'm doing, the safety of what I'm doing, whatever that looks like?
So if somebody's having bacon and eggs, and that person is obviously not me, to make bacon and eggs, the chicken is involved, but the pig is committed. And we were not pigs. You know, in a business, and I think there are different schools on this, but in the business, my rule was I pay myself last. I've gotta pay my staff first. I've gotta pay all the overheads of the business, and whatever's left, that's what I get to keep. Sometimes there was more, sometimes there was less, sometimes there was below zero.
But that's taking a risk. It means that you are prepared for the uneven outcomes. Okay. So then by definition, the safety nets are nice, but it's the propensity for - uncertainty. - For uncertainty, for variable - outcomes. - Yeah. Yep. Mind if I switched gears? So I had this thought that's going to be... I think there's an irony in some respects to forging your early career life, so to speak, into not being defined by somebody else's legacy and building your own, and yet simultaneously building something through which you could easily have been defined.
It is almost, yes, it now becomes my definition. I'm defined by the thing I've built as opposed to being abstract. Does that make sense? Hang on, I don't - understand. - So I'm thinking about there's somebody else's idea, and I'm, I could easily fall into living that. There's the idea that I want to build something for myself. I want to be seen to be doing that. But then you could easily be hitched to that. That's the thing that I do now. That's my identity tied to that, like a lot of business owners are.
And so if your philosophy is to not be tied to somebody else's idea or any particular idea, how do you live that? Or at what point do you go, "This is not me anymore, and there's a new version of me," and how do you separate - that? - Right. I decided relatively early that I didn't want my business to become a family business. And I'm trying to remember what exactly informed that. But I think one of the pivotal things was when a prospect said to me, and the company was, you know, we had a few staff at the moment, but it was me, you know, leading it.
He said, "This is all very good, but what if you get hit by a bus?" And I thought about it a lot afterwards and realised that he was right, that the business was overly dependent on me. And I set about changing that. So there were a few things that informed it. One was that I realised that the business is only worth something if it's worth something to somebody else. It's not enough for it to be an engine of generating cash. And that links to the lifestyle side of things.
Is the business there to serve you, or are you there to serve the business? And we had a young growing family, and my wife was from the US, and we visited there regularly. And I'm thinking, "How can I make that compatible with being a business owner?" And that became almost a litmus test of the growth of the business. Can the business keep going and doing its day-to-day stuff if I'm not physically there? And that... and those were milestones for me. So making the business worth something besides... with... without me was a clear goal, and it was...
There was a fantastic piece of advice that I got from somebody. I had... At one stage, I wanted to grow the business, and I sought to bring somebody in who would be in a biz dev role while I could continue to do the stuff that I wanted to do, which was the back office geeky stuff. And after three months in the business, he said to me, that's not what I should be doing. Instead of hiring a biz dev person, I should be the biz dev person because I, as the owner, as the person who has the passion for the business, is the best person to be out there promoting and selling and marketing, and instead I should hire an operations manager.
And that was one of the best pieces of advice for that business, and it's a piece of advice I still give business owners now. So all of that said to me... And then there was also seeing my father, who was a micromanager, who... And again, this is informed by his wartime experience. Micromanagers are people who can't trust others to do their job. They've got to keep checking on them. You know, is everyone doing what they should be doing? And I didn't like that. First of all, I was a more trusting person based on my upbringing.
But second of all, I saw that's, you know, an impediment to growth. I can't do this business myself. I've got to get other people on the journey with me. So what's my job as a leader? My job as a leader is to enlist followers, to have people who are on the journey who can do the things that I either didn't wanna do or couldn't do, because we still haven't invented cloning. So you took me on a bit of a mental rollercoaster there. Let me try and reconcile where we've got to.
So I was curious about whether your desire to be, do your own thing, ha- forge your own path, then p- had the potential to land you in a scenario where you're now, your identity is tied to the thing you've built. And as you were starting to answer, I said, "Oh, okay, I can see why that wasn't gonna happen by virtue of we're family, we're travelling, and I'm being deliberate around how I structured the business." And then you came back to, "But also, I learned a really good piece of advice, which is you need to be the front of this because you're the driving force and you love it." And I'm like, "Wow, we've come full circle back to this could easily be your identity once again." And I'm curious what happened next?
Ah, okay. So yes, I was the face of the business, and the operations manager was successively become more s- became more senior and then became general manager. And at that point, the business was still being run by the seat of my pants, and I was 100% owner. And the general manager and I, we actually, we weren't working well together. And I had... The business was, had some very rapid growth, and then we were suffering because we were hiring people too quickly and had growing pains. And then one of the other businesses that I had was involved in a partnership that was a basket case of a business.
Never succeeded. Had to close that down, which was quite difficult. And I'm thinking, "What am I gonna do? This is not working with the general manager." And I had two pieces of advice. One was from my father, who said, "Sack that general manager and go run it yourself properly." Exactly those words. And that typified my father's micromanager approach. You have to be running this. You have to be in charge. You have to be... have an eye on everything that's happening throughout the whole business, otherwise it can't succeed.
And then I had advice from another person who was an experienced non-exec director, and he said, "The path is to turn that general manager into a CEO role, to separate yourself operationally from the business." And because I was on that journey anyway, but I was sort of, you know, half-pregnant. Was I in the business or not in the business? And that was the reason for the conflict. I was doing stuff, she was doing stuff, and we were stepping on each other's toes. So he said, "Set up an advisory board, and have a proper delegation from ownership to management." And, wouldn't you know it, that's the advice that I took rather than my father's advice because that was...
My father's advice was counter to everything I was trying to achieve, that this business be worth something without me, be able to run on its own, so to speak, or rather under my direction. And by that time, I had been in a number of non-profit roles and understood a lot more about the governance and strategy and the role of a board in a business. So I set up an advisory board, and obviously, that general manager who became the CEO, she didn't last. But the next CEO, he was excellent because he came from a... being a business owner himself.
He understood what it was like, and we played off each other really well. 'Cause I was 100% owner, but he was CEO, and people would circumvent him, and I would push back. I'd say, "He's the CEO. Talk to him." You know, and they would say, "Oh, David, can you do a deal? We've been in business for a long time." And I'd say, "Well, hang on. My CEO's got his KPIs. Do you want me to tell him to expect him to meet his KPIs with hands tied behind his back?" And we played that really well because we were using the authority element of Harvard seven el- Harvard seven elements, that Getting to Yes framework, where even though I had 100% ownership and all authority, I abdicated some of that authority to the CEO to empower the CEO to do his job.
And that worked very well. So that was my way to sort of say, "Okay, I want to now set this business up to be something not bound to my identity," as you asked. That led to me doing a master's of entrepreneurship. That led to me carving my new career as a family enterprise adviser, which was writing my next chapter while my current chapter was still going, and that is the most important thing to do. That's engineering a smooth transition with overlap between the two careers, so that by the time I sold that tech business last year, I was only spending 10 to 20% of my time on it and I was literally able to walk away and never have anything to do with it again, because by that time, my career as a family enterprise adviser had traction.
So I guess the question is: is letting go of control easier than letting go of relevance? Oh, wow. I love the way you framed that. Control and relevance. So for some people, being in control is their relevance. For me, being... I was able to give up control, and it was not... I was not irrelevant. I was still the founder, the owner, the leader as opposed to the manager. Okay? And separating that is very important. There's a family I work with, the... I helped them transition the MD role from the father to one of the sons.
And the father was staying. He... The R word, retirement, was absolutely forbidden. He was... still had plenty in him, still has plenty in him. But we had to design a whole new role for him, and we called him founder chair, which acknowledged, say he was chair of the board, and he acknowledged him as the founder. And so he was giving up some control, needed to remain relevant, but they weren't tied together. But I think that un... What's the word? Disentangling of control and relevance is really essential. 'Cause if it is tied together, as soon as you lose control, you lose relevance.
You don't have to lose relevance just by giving up control. Okay? Because that's the difference between ownership and management, between leadership and management. You can be the leader, you can be the face, you can be the, you know, it's your name on the business, all of those things, without having, without controlling the day-to-day. And in fact, there's limits on how much you can control, you know? Can I role play something with you? Sure. I'm your old man. Tell me that story. Which one? Control and relevance? Yeah.
Why I should give it up. Why you should give it up? At some point, we are going to have roles, positions of control and power within the family enterprise. How's that gonna happen? Is it gonna happen when you're no longer here, or can it happen while you're still here and we can receive your guidance and direction? Because if I wanna be good at something, I've gotta start practising it. I can't suddenly, you know, be studying it and then in a situation of what we call an unplanned succession, suddenly be stuck into the... thrust into the role without that mentor, without that guidance, without that "What do you think?", you know?
And this, it goes to, you know, parenthood. It goes to how parenthood transitions when your kids grow up, because this is very much related to how to be a parent to adult children. I put it to you that if I'm your old man, is my response not the fact that you need me around to ask questions proves you're not ready? Not ready. That's, you know, a term that's bandied around in families so much. And for every parent who says the kids aren't ready, I challenge them in saying, "Maybe it's you who are not ready." It's interesting because, you know, you've got to...
I... it's about smooth transitions, okay? Because the best successions are not events. They are unnoticeable. Okay? Because by the time you have that formal change of role, this person is... was the MD yesterday, and this person's the MD today, the... that person, the incoming, has had sufficient experience and mentoring and guidance on the job to say, "I'm now comfortable in this role myself." And the shift on that day is actually relatively small, because equally, the incumbent leader has had enough guidance and mentoring to say, "This is what life looks like for you when your child is in the box seat." And if they both don't have it, then it may be setting up for failure.
So then in the scenario where you're one of five, and brothers, sisters, whomever have been in the business for decades, on that "I'm learning the business", and you've not been in it, does that present the challenge to your smooth transition that you haven't learned through the business to understand what's next? Absolutely. Okay? Because as soon as you go from, as you often do, from G1 to G2, from one person as an owner to more than one person as an owner, a whole new set of skills need to be learned.
And it starts with communication. It starts with having areas of responsibility. You c... You know, how many companies can successfully run with co-CEOs? And that's assuming two. Okay? What if there's more than two? So anybody who thinks a succession is a passing of one to one, where there's more than one successor, more, or sorry, more than one in the next generation, is not getting the whole picture. Because where does that leave what they call the unchosen one? Okay? If there's one chosen one, that means there's as many kids as you have minus one unchosen ones.
What are their roles? And what we speak about is the skill of learning to be an owner. And you wouldn't think ownership is a skill, but it is. I don't need any... to learn any skill to become an owner of BHP. I can just, in five seconds on my phone, become an owner. On the other hand, if I am the rising generation in a family enterprise where there is, might be operating business and investment and all of those things, being an owner of that, a foundation, okay?
Being an owner of that, the better word to use is being a steward. Because ownership has connotations of mine, mine, all mine. Okay? Stewardship is this humility to say, "I'm part of a story that's bigger than me. It was here before me. Hopefully, it'll be here after me, and I'm the person who happens to be the steward for this period of - time." - This is interesting. So with all that in mind, how did your... you and your siblings approach that conversation - with your old man? - Oh, we didn't.
It was whatever he said. Oh. My mission as a family enterprise adviser is to help other families do it well. It's informed by a lived experience of something that could have been so much better. Okay. Hmm. That was not where I thought you were gonna go. That's all - right. - No, we didn't have those discussions, and we still don't really have those discussions, - unfortunately. - No. We don't have any of the family discussions that we should be having. And it's pretty... You know, it's a... what do they call it?
A cautionary tale. So, so much of my family I've learned what not to do. But if you haven't, if you don't learn that, then you're doomed to repeat it. That's the most important thing, learning from the past and breaking intergenerational cycles. I have a lot of respect for my parents. They were very successful. They were very good parents, very loving parents. But like all humans, they had their limitations. So how do you frame that? You frame it as, "Okay, they taught me something." "They taught me something really important." You've got your own kids.
What lesson have you learnt that you're going to deliberately not pass on? I love that, because, you know, my own family experience has been fabulously informative, and I think with our parents, there's always two categories of things. There's the stuff in which we wanna be exactly like them, and there's the stuff we wanna be the opposite. Okay? So my father, micromanager, me, over-delegator. I actually overcompensated. Okay? The... again, going back to Jay Hughes, Jay Hughes says, "Founders create wealth, heirs create d... create legacy." So, you know, every day I ask myself, "What can I learn from my family?
How to do things for my generation, for our children and our descendants into, to building that legacy?" And a lot of the learnings have been things that I would do differently and I am doing differently. You know, and it starts with communication, open communication, because communication and trust go hand in hand. The most important currency a family has is trust. You know, you ask, "Are you ready? Are the kids ready?" When anybody ever says that to you, what are they saying? They're saying, "I don't trust you." But people will tend to rise to both their ability and the extent to which they're empowered.
And if they're disempowered, then that will stifle their growth, you know? In a way, I needed to get out and do my own thing so as not to put a cap on myself, and let the caps be the natural caps of my own ability or capacity. So, you know, I've learned that the most important thing is communication, sharing em... and empowering my children. I want them to all be the best they can be, and the question I have to ask myself as a parent is, "How can I enable that?" How can I not be something that is limiting their ability to live their best lives?
How can I create... And this is a, you know, there's a framework of, again, Jay Hughes' five forms of family capital. Financial capital is just one of them. But things like social capital, the ability of a family to work together towards a common goal. That's something that doesn't happen by itself. Whether it's saying to the kids, "Organise where we're going for dinner," or decide how we're gonna invest a pool of money or allegate... allocate a philanthropic gift. Those activities build social capital. It teaches the kids to learn to do things together.
I've got this one client. He's... and he wants to teach his kids how to invest. So I gave him a few ideas. And the next meeting, he's already created some structures and given the kids a pool of money to invest with. And, you know, so we're setting up all the infrastructure to help them do that, and setting some goals for them on education. And I said to them at the meeting, "You know, what if we set up a third pool of money, which is for the kids to invest together?
Then they'll learn the additional skill of negotiating with each other and reaching, you know, consensus." And I said, "Stop. Don't do it yet. Give them some time to learn on their own." But again, that's another skill to learn. Teaching kids to collaborate or... No, better. Creating the space and the circumstance through which they will learn to collaborate. So then what's going through my head is if the... If you had the, call it opportunity, for lack of a better term, to go, "I wanna forge my own path and do something different," and from that you've learned what you don't wanna pass on and what you do, what observations have you made of your other siblings, who weren't necessarily afforded the same opportunity, that have informed the way you think now?
Everybody's got a choice. And everybody, you know, everybody holds on to narratives. In families in particular, narratives are really important because those are the stories we tell ourselves about our family, which may or may not relate to fact. And challenging narratives, challenging family stereotypes, "You're the this one, you're the that one," that's a really important thing to do. So, you know, each of us have, are doing our own thing and have our different narratives on our own family. And I say the best thing I can do is allow my kids... do my best to empower my kids to, you know, create fertile ground for them to grow and become whatever they wanna become.
And never act to hold that back. And so the next obvious question would be how many of them are gonna come into the family business? But as you said, you deliberately didn't build a - family business. - I didn't build a family business, so I don't have an operating business that is... I have from time to time employed my kids when they needed it. I have started a business with one of my kids, which is an investment business, a q... an emerging quant fund. Another one of my kids is looking to start, starting a business, but it's really just him, but I'm supporting him and helping him do that.
So, but at the same time, I n... I do not wanna raise kids who are, you know, grow up to be beneficiaries. Okay? We talk about a generative family. That means every generation, and thank God we've got five kids and more than that in grandkids. And the simple maths of being fruitful and multiplying will diminish family wealth bloody fast. So you've gotta make sure that each of the kids is saying, "I'm here to contribute to the family enterprise," whether or not you own an operating business or not.
You know, it might be managing investments, it might be investing in businesses, investing in entrepreneurship that's gonna grow the wealth faster than the family can grow so the family can enjoy it. And of course, the other part is philanthropy. Doing that in a meaningful way so that you can make that part of your legacy too. So I'm learning. I'm still learning, and I'm still making mistakes. But, you know, everyone makes mistakes 'cause we're human. The question is can we learn from them? And on that note, I think, my friend, it might be time for us to wrap up.
Appreciate you sharing a drink with me and sharing your story. Thanks so much. I've loved every second of it. Today's shout is the Hellyers Road peated seven-year-old single malt, sourced from a amazing family business up in Burnie in Tasmania. And the story goes that the family actually has second, third and fourth generation folks working in the business, and the interesting part about it is it's not just a single family. It's actually a bunch of multi-generational family businesses who have a history in the dairy co-op space, who now are running a amazing Tasmanian distillery, and this was a really good drop, so you should try it.
Cheers. Thanks for listening to My Shout. It's been amazing having you on board. If you like the show, I'd love for you to share it with your friends, join us on the socials, hit the follow button and let everyone know about these great family business transition stories. Thanks for listening.
David Werdiger grew up knowing there was a place for him in the family business. He chose not to take it. Instead, he wanted to find out what he could build on his own merits, eventually creating a technology business and deliberately making it less dependent on him.
That experience shaped how he now thinks about succession. David and Shane talk about identity inside a successful family, the difference between ownership and management, why the next generation needs room to practise responsibility and what happens when control becomes tied to relevance. They also return to something more personal: what we inherit from our families, what we choose to carry forward and what we deliberately do differently.
Today’s Shout is a Hellyers Road Peated 7 Year Old Single Malt from Burnie, Tasmania.
About David Werdiger
David Werdiger helps family enterprises navigate intergenerational wealth transitions and make good decisions together. His diverse background gives him a powerful mix of skills and he brings all parts of himself together in unique and innovative ways. David is a best-selling author on wealth transition, an experienced non-executive director, second generation family member and family office principal, a dynamic speaker and educator, and faculty at the UHNW Institute. He is founder of the Power of Pause Institute.
Website: https://davidwerdiger.com/
LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/davidwerdiger
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/dwerdiger
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/dwerdiger/